Being likeable may help to reduce tensions; however, it does not mean that trust is built.
For managers and leaders, it is important to focus on whether people can rely on me for challenging situations, clearly and early, instead of if people like me.
The Radical Candour framework by Kim Scott highlights the two essential duties of caring personally and challenging directly.
If challenge is carried out without care, then it becomes a kind of aggression. If one cares without offering challenge, it results in empathy, which, by safeguarding today’s comfort, harms tomorrow’s performance.
The need to be liked can make avoiding someone seem rational. Feedback is postponed because the moment feels improper. A flawed decision is upheld because its proponent holds a higher rank. Behaviour that could be corrected hardens into a habit.
The honest conversation does take place, but it happens in the corridor and not with the person who needs to hear it most.
Psychological safety does not mean the absence of discomfort or a lack of accountability. In her 1999 study of 51 teams, Amy Edmondson identified a link between psychological safety and learning behaviour. The study concluded that silence does not eliminate failure; rather, it prevents organisations from recognising and rectifying it.
Feedback should be given on time, be specific, and concentrate on the topic/challenge/behaviour itself and its consequences. Leaders need to state their concern, listen to people’s point of view, agree on the next step, and then follow up.
It is recommended to deliver criticism privately, while praise can often be given in public. Honesty should also move upward; a leader who encourages challenges but replies defensively sends the message to the team that honesty is only safe when it supports authority.
The desire to be likely aims at gaining approval, while Radical Candour is willing to accept some degree of discomfort in order to promote clarity, growth, and respect; trust is built when a leader speaks the truth thoughtfully, listens in turn, and stays present afterwards.